Gold Items from southern Bulgaria and western Anatolia in the Early Bronze Age: An attempt for comparison. Preliminary observations and notes in the context of gold finds from Dabene
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.57573/be-ja.16.21-43Keywords:
Gold finds, Early Bronze Age, Dabene, Troy, Poliohny, EskiaparAbstract
This text examines the gold objects found in southern Bulgaria, with an emphasis on those from the ritual structures near Dabene, Karlovo and similar ones from Troy, Poliochny and Eskiapar in Anatolia.
An attempt is made to make a general typological comparison between them, and attention is also paid to the technology of manufacture. The level of likeness of the objects is pointed out, as well as the similarities and variations in the technology of production as far as it is known.
On this basis, the similarities and differences in the complex materials in the two regions compared in the text, southern Bulgaria and western Anatolia, are assessed. It is assumed that the territory of southern Bulgaria has a special place in the production and use of gold objects and complex ornaments. These are typologically different from those known in western Anatolia.
Downloads
References
Agre, D. 2007. Arheologicheski razkopki na nadgrobna mogila v zemlishteto na s. Popovo, obshtina Bolyarovo, Yambolska oblast. Arheologicheski otkritia i razkopki prez 2006 g. Sofia, 74–75 (in Bulgarian).
Agre, D. 2018. Hair-ring. Cat. no. 169. In Alexandrov, St., Dimitrova, Y., Popov, H., Horejs, B., Chukalev, K. (eds) Gold & Bronze. Metals, Technologies and Interregional Contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 479.
Alexandrov, S. 2007. Zlatni nakiti ot mogilen grob ot II hil. pr. Hr. do s. Ovchartsi, obshtina Radnevo. In Tacheva, M., Dimitrova, S., Ivanova, E., Valchev, G., Yankov, D., Minkova, M. (eds) Sbornik v chest na st. n. s. Hristo Buyukliev. Izvestia na istoricheski muzei Stara Zagora, 2. Stara Zagora: RMH–Stara Zagora, 74–84 (in Bulgarian).
Alexandrov, S. 2017a. Ukrashenia ot blagorodni metali ot rannata bronzova epoha vav fonda na Natsionalnia arheologicheski institute s muzei. In Popov, H., Tzvetkova, J. (eds) KRATISTOS. Sbornik v chest na professor Petar Delev. Sofia: University Publishing House “St. Kl. Ohrisdski”, 215–227 (in Bulgarian).
Alexandrov, S. 2017b. Der Hortfund nahe Petrič. In Haag, S., Popov, C., Horejs, B., Alexandrov, S., Plattner, G. (eds) Das erste Gold. Ada Tepe: Das älteste Goldbergwerk Europas (OREA 7). Wien: Kunst Historisches Museum–Wien, 124–125.
Alexandrov, S. 2018. Early Bronze Age Tumular Grave near Troyanovo, Radnevo Region. In Alexandrov, S., Dimitrova, Y., Popov, H., Horejs, B., Chukalev, K. (еds) Gold & Bronze. Metals, Technologies and Interregional Contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 323–324.
Alexandrov, S. 2020. Gold and Silver Ornaments in Early and Middle Brone Age Bulgaria. In Maran, J., Băjenaru, R., Ailincăi, S.-C., Popescu, A.-D., Hansen, S. (eds) Objects, Ideas and Travelers Contacts between the Balkans, the Aegean and Western Anatolia during the Bronze and Early Iron Age. Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GMBH, 251–263.
Alexandrov, St., Hristov, M. 2018. Early Bronze Age Hoards from Petrich Region, Southwest Bulgaria. In Alexandrov, St., Dimitrova, Y., Popov, H., Horejs, B., Chukalev, K. (еds) Gold & Bronze. Metals, Technologies and Interregional Contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 332–334.
Alexandrov, St., Iliev, I., Oberc, T., Podsiadlo, M., Valchev, T., Wlodarczak, P. 2024. Barrow at Pamukli Bair in Malomirovo, Elhovo municipality. In Alexandrov, S., Wlodarczak, P. (eds) From the Steppes to the Balkans. Yamna Culture in Upper Thrace. Budapest: Archaeolingua Foundation, 77–165.
Alexandrov, S., Agre, D. 2024. Malomirovo, Precious Metal Jewellery. In Alexandrov, St., Wlodarczak, P. (eds) From the Steppes to the Balkans. Yamna Culture in Upper Thrace. Budapest: Archaeolingua Foundation, 167–173.
Avilova, L. 2018. Anatoliiskie kladai metalicheskih izdelii. Ocherki metaloproizvodstva i kulturnogo konteksta. Moskva: IA–RAN.
Avramova, M. 2002. Mobiler Funérire. In Devisscher, H. (ed.) L’or des Thrace. Bruxelles: Snoeck-Ducaju & Zoon Gent, 57–58.
Bachmann, H.-G. 2006. The Lure of Gold. New York–London: Abbeville Press.
Balabanov, P., Pantov, D. 2019. Nadgrobna mogila Silihyar 4. Arheologicheski otkritia i razkopki prez 2018 g. Sofia, 106–109 (in Bulgarian).
Balabanov, P., Pantov, D. 2022. Pogrebeniya ot bronzovata epoha v m. Silihyar krai Promorsko. Izvestia na Burgaskia myzei 8.1, 44–60 (in Bulgarian).
Bass, G.F. 1966. Troy and Ur. Expedition 8.4, 26–39.
Bass, G.F. 1970. A Hoard of Trojan and Sumerian Jewelry. Amercan Journal of Archaeology 74.4, 335–341.
Betancourt, P. 2006. Joining Techniques in Early Bronze Age Trojan Jewelry. Studia Troica 16, 89–95.
Bernabò-Brea, L. 1976. Poliochni città preistorica nell’isola di Lemnos. V. II, part 2. Roma: L’erma di Bretschneder.
Bojadzhiev, Y. 2007. Tell Yunatsite – absolyutnaya hronologiya gorizontov epohi rannei bronzy. In Tell Yunatsite, vol. II–1. Moscow: Vostochnaya literatura Publishers, 217–221.
Born, H., Schlosser, S., Schwab, R., Paz, B., Pernicka, E. 2009. Granuliertes gold aus Troia in Berlin. Restaurierung und Archäologie 2, 19–30.
Buyukliev, H. 1964. Dve rannotrakiiski pogrebenia ot Starozagorsko. Arheologia VI.4, 63–65 (in Bulgarian).
Christov, M. 2008a. On the age of some gold artefacts from the Kraishte Region in South-West Bulgaria. In Kostov, R.I., Gaydarska, B., Gurova, M. (eds) Geoarchaelogy and Archaeomineralogy. Proceedings of the International Conference, 29–30 October 2008. Sofia: “St. Ivan Rilski”, 219–221.
Christov, M. 2008b. Preliminary observations on the gold spirals from the ritual structures near Dubene, Karlovo region. In Kostov, R.I., Gaydarska, B., Gurova, M. (eds) Geoarchaelogy and Archaeomineralogy. Proceedings of the International Conference, 29–30 October 2008. Sofia: “St. Ivan Rilski”, 222–224.
Dimitrova, D., Markov, M., Sirakov, N. 2012. Prouchvane na Shekerdzha mogila pri s. Kamen, Slivensko. Arheologicheski otkritia i razkopki prez 2011 g. Sofia, 109–111 (in Bulgarian).
Dimitrova, D. 2012a. Mogili ot bronzovata epoha pri s. Kamen, Slivensko. In Dimitrov, Z. (ed.) Balgarska arheologia 2011, katalog kam izlozhba. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 13–15 (in Bulgarian).
Dimitrova, D. 2012b. Tsarskiat orel ot Shekerdzha mogila. Buditel 1, 37–45 (in Bulgarian).
Easton, D. 2003. A Pair of Pendent Earrings of Trojan Type. Studia Troica 10, 240–250.
Garašanin, D. 1954. Katalog metala. Praistoria I. Beograd: Narodni muzej.
Garašanin, M. 1983. Dubovačko–Žutobrdska Grupa. Praistorija Jugoslavenskih Zemalja IV, 520–535.
Georgieva, R., Nikov, K., Momchilov, D. 2008. Tonchova mogila krai s. Venets, Karnobatsko. Archeologicheski otrkitia i razkopki prez 2007 g. Sofia, 231–232 (in Bulgarian).
Georgieva, R., Nikov, K., Hristova, R. 2018. Early Bronze Age Tumular Graves near Venets, Karnobat Region. In Alexandrov, S., Dimitrova, Y., Popov, H., Horejs, B., Chukalev, K. (eds) Gold & Bronze. Metals, Technologies and Interregional Contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 328–329.
Heyd, V., Aydıngün, Ş., Güldoğan, Е. 2016. Kanlıgeçit – Selimpaşa – Mikhalich and the Question of Anatolian Colonies in Early Bronze Age Southeast Europe. In Molloy, B.P.C. (ed.) Of Odysseys and Oddities. Scales and modes of interaction between prehistoric Aegean societies and their neighbours (Sheffield Studies in Aegaen Archaeology 10). Oxford–Philadelfia: Oxbow, 169–202.
Hristov, M. 2005. Mogilen nekropol ot rannata bronzova epoha krai Dubene, Karlovsko (predvaritelno saobshtenie). Arheologia XLVI.1–4, 127–137 (in Bulgarian).
Hristov, M. 2010. Early Bronze Age ritual structures and cemetery at Dabene, near Karlovo (preliminary report). Studia Preahistorica XLVI.13, 193–317.
Hristov, M. 2011. Interdisciplinary study of materials from the ritual structures at the village of Dabene, near Karlovo. In Nikolov, V., Bacvarov, K., Popov, H. (eds) Interdisziplinäre Forschungen zum Kulturerbe auf der Balkanhalbinsel. Sofia: Humboldt-Union in Bulgarien, 139–149.
Hristov, M. 2015. New evidence for funeral and ritual activity in the northern part of the Balkan Peninsula: a case study from Southern Bulgaria in the second half of the 3rd to the first half of the 2nd millennium BC. In Meller, H., Arz, H.W., Jung, R., Risch, R. (Hrsg.) 2200 BC – Ein Klimasturg als Ursache für den Zerfall der Alten Welt? 7. Mitteldeutscher Archäologentag vom 23. bis 26. Oktober in Halle (Saale) (Tagungen des Landesmuseum für Vorgeschichte Halle. Band 12/II). Halle: Landesmuseum für Vorgeschihte, 483–501.
Hristov, M.G. 2016. Dubene and its Probable Contacts with the Aegaeo-Anatolian Region. In Pernicka, E., Ünlüsoy, S., Blum, S. (eds) Early Bronze Age Troy: Chronology, Cultural Development and Interregional Contacts. Proceedings of an International Conference held at the University of Tübingen May 8–10, 2009 (Studia Troica. Monographien 8). Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GMBH, 229–237.
Hristov, M. 2017. Sakrovishtata ot Dabene. Sofia: National Museum of History (in Bulgarian).
Hristov, M. G. 2022. Two daggers from precious metal from Upperthrace lowland. Acta Musei Tiberiopolitani 4, 57–63.
Hristov, M., Karatsanova, V. 2009. On the Function of the Particular Type of Gold Artifacts from the Bronze Age in Southeasr Europe and Asia Minorr. Thracia XVIII, 443–449.
Iliev, Il. 2011. The Pit Grave culture in the lower Tundzha valley. Studia Praehistorica 14, 381 – 398.
Katincharov, R., Avramova, M. 1994. Edno ochakvano sakrovishte. Problemi na izkustvoto, 4, 4–5 (in Bulgarian).
Kavur, M.B., Mitrović, J.D. 2023. Bosut Glod. In Govedarica, B., Vranić, I., Kapuran, A. (eds) A Step into the Past. Approaches to Identity, Communications and Material Culture in South-Eastern European Archaeology. Papers dedicated to Petar Popović for his 78th birthday. Belgrade: Institute of Archaeology, 49–64.
Krauß, R. 2017. Die Mittelbronzezeit an der unteren Donau. In Haag, S., Popov, Ch., Horejs, B., Alexandrov, S., Plattner, G. (eds) Das erste Gold. Ada Tepe: Das älteste Goldbergwerk Europas. Wien: Kunsthistorisches Museum, 35–41.
Krauß, R. 2018. The Middle Bronze Age on the Lower Danube. In Alexandrov, S., Dimitrova, Y., Popov, H., Horejs, B., Chukalev, K. (eds) Gold & Bronze. Metals, Technologies and Interregional Contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 151–159.
Krauß, R., Pernicka, E. 2023. A Bronze Knife from Site 3. In Vagalinski, L., Conrad, S., Krauß, R. (eds) Novgrad – Tash Bair I. Archaeological Investigations at the Southernmost of the Danube (Archaeological excavations and research, 48.1). Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 431–434.
Leshtakov, K. 1996. Trade Centres from Early Bronze Age III and Middle Bronze Age in Upper Thrace (Notes on the Interpretation of Baa Dere – Konstantia – Gulubovo). In Nikolova L. (ed.) Reports of Prehistoric Research Project, vol. 1, no. 2–4. Sofia: Prehistory foundation, 239–287
Leshtakov, K. 2006. Bronzovata epoha v Gornotrakiiskata nizina. Godishnik na Sofiiskia universitet “Sv. Kliment Ohridski”. Istoricheski fakultet – spetsialnost Arheologia 3, 141–216 (in Bulgarian).
Leshtakov, K. 2008. New Evidence on the LBA Mortuary Practices in South Bulgaria. In Özbek, О. (ed.) Funeral Rites, Rituals and Ceremonies from Prehistory to Antiquity. Istanbul: Institut Français D’Études Anatoliennes, 69–82.
Lilyquist, C. 1993. Granulation and Glass: Chronological and Stylistic Investigations at Selected Sites, ca. 2500–1400 B.C.E. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 290/291, 29–94.
Maran, J. 2007. Seaborne Contacts between the Aegean, the Balkans and the Central Mediterranean in the 3rd Millennium BC – The Unfolding of the Mediterranean World. In Galanaki, I., Tomas, H., Galanakis, Y., Laffineur, R. (eds) Between the Aegean and the Baltic Seas. Prehistory Across the Borders. Liege–Austin: KLEIMO SA Eupen, 3–24.
Maxwell-Hyslop, K.R. 1971. Western Asiatic Jewellery c. 3000–612 B.C. London: Methuen & Co LTD.
Medovič, P. 2006. Vojvodina u Praistoriji. Novi Sad: Platoneum.
Mikov, V. 1940. Selishtnata mogila Yunatsite, Pazardzhishko. Godishnik na plovdivskata narodna biblioteka i muzei, 1937–1939, 55–75 (in Bulgarian).
Mitkova, R. 2011. Nahodki ot selishtnata mogila Yunatsite vav fonda na Regionalen arheologicheski muzei – Plovdiv. In Boyadzhiev, Y., Ignatova-Terziiska, S. (eds) Zlatnoto peto hilyadoletie. Trakia i sasednite raioni prez kamenno-mednata epoha. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 67–71 (in Bulgarian).
Nikov, K. 2024. New evidence for relations between Southern Thrace and Anatolia in the late third and early second millennia BCE. In Grömer, K., Krenn-Leeb, A., Binder, M. (еds) Prähistorisches Gold. Wien: Druckerei Print Alliance HAV Produktions GmbH, 111–117.
Özgüç, T., Temizer, R. 1993. The Eskiyapar Treasure. In Mellink, M.J., Porada, E., Özgüç, T. (eds) Aspects of Art and Iconography: Anatolia and its Neighbors. Studies in Honor of Nimet Özgüç. Ankara: Türk Tahir Kurumu Basimevi, 613–628.
Popescu, A.-D. 2003. Bone Accessory of a Bronze Age Necklace. Dacia 43–44, 17–30.
Popescu, A.-D. 2020. Prestige Artefacts during the Bronze Age: The Perşinari Hoard and the Precious Metal Weapons in the Area between the Middle Danube and Mesopotamia. In Maran, J., Băjenaru, R., Ailincăi, S.-C., Popescu, A.-D., Hansen, S. (eds) Objects, Ideas and Travelers Contacts between the Balkans, the Aegean and Western Anatolia during the Bronze and Early Iron Age. Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GMBH, 221–249.
Primas, M. 1996. Velika Gruda I. Bonn: Kommission bei R. Habelt.
Sazci, G. 2006. Der Schatzfundhorizont in Troia – seine Einordung innerhalb des Grabungsplatzes und der bronzrzeitlichen Welt. Archäologisches Nachrichtenblatt 11.3, 245–251.
Sazci, G. 2007. The Treasures of Troja. Wien: Aygaz.
Sazci, G., Trejster, M. 2006. Troias Gold – Die Schätze des dritten Jahrtausends vor Christus. In Korfmann, M. (ed.) Troia Archäologie eines Siedlungshügels und seiner Landschaft. Mainz: Philipp von Zabern, 209–218.
Srejovič, D. 1976. Humke stepskih odlika na teritoriji Srbije. Godišnak Centar za Balkanološka Izpitivanja 13.2, 117–130.
Tolstikov, V.P., Trejster, M., König, C. (eds) 1996. Der Schatz aus Troja. Schliemann und der Mythos des Priamos–Goldes. Katalog. Stuttgart–Zürih: Belser Verlag.
Trejster, M. 1996. Die trojanischen Schätze. In Tolstikov, V. P., Trejster, M. Ju., König, Ch. (eds) Der Schatz aus Troja. Schliemann und der Mythos des Priamos-Goldes. Katalog. Stuttgart–Zürih: Belser Verlag, 197–236.
Treister, M. 2013. Troyansie kladai. In Piotrovskii, Y.Y. (ed.) Bronzovai vek. Evropa bez granits. Chetvertoe – pervoe taisyacheletia do n.e. Katalog vaistavki. Sankt Peterburg: Tabula Rasa Publishing House, 140–155.
Tsaneva, S., Hristov, M., Karatsanova, V., Tsintsov, Z. 2011a. Arheometrichni prouchvania na zlatni nahodki ot Rannata Bronzova epoha III, ot mestnostta “Balinov gorun”, do s. Dabene, Karlovsko. Izvestia na Natsionalnia istoricheski muzei 23, 9–26 (in Bulgarian).
Tsaneva, S., Hristov, M., Karatsanova, V., Tsintsov. Z. 2011b. The SEM-EDAX Story of a Small Early Bronze Age Gold Find from the Locality of Balinov Gorun, Karlovo Region. Archeologica Bulgarica XV.2, 15–23.
Tsintsov, Z.L. 1992. Unique Finds of Golden Articles in Alluvial Placers. Dokladi na Balgarskata academia na naukite 45.6, 59–61.
Tsintsov, Z. 1993. Aluvialnite zlatni sakrovishta na Balgaria. Priroda 1, 43–52 (in Bilgarian).
Tsintsov, Z. 2005. Gold artefacts from the Alluvial Sediments of Bulgaria – Indicators for Gold Mining and Metallurgy During the Bronze Age. In Yanev, Y., Nedyalkov, R. (eds) Proceeding of Anniversary International Scientific Conference “80th years Bulgarian Geological Society”. Sofia: Balgarsko geologichesko druzhestvo, 217–229.
Tsintsov, Z. 2008. Distribution and Typology of Gold Atrefacts from the Bronze Age in the Alluvial Sediments in Bulgaria. In Kostov, R.I., Gaydarska, B., Gurova, M. (eds) Geoarchaelogy and Archaeomineralogy. Proceedings of the International Conference, 29–30 October 2008. Sofia: “St. Ivan Rilski”, 216–218.
Tsintsov, Z. 2018. The Long Guarded “Precious” Secrets from the Alluvial Sediments. The Placer Gold in Present-Day Bulgaria. In Alexandrov, S., Dimitrova, Y., Popov, H., Horejs, B., Chukalev, K. (eds) Gold & Bronze. Metals, Technologies and Interregional Contacts in the Eastern Balkans during the Bronze Age. Sofia: NAIM–BAS, 59–69.
Tsintsov, Z., Hristov, M., Karatsanova, V., Tsaneva, S. 2009. Preliminary Results from the Study of Early Bronze Age Gold Artefacts from Some Ritual Structures from Balinov Gorun Locality, Village of Dubene, Karlovo Region. Archeologica Bulgarica XIII.3, 7–21.
Vasileva, J. 2017. The Early Bronze Age Rings of Type Leukas – New Considerations Regarding Their Origin, Distribution and Function. Archaeologia Bulgarica XXI.1, 1–13.
Vasileva, J. 2025. Jewellery production in Thrace and the Aegaean during 3rd millennium BC (Dissertationes 20). Sofia: NAIM–BAS.
Wolters, J. 1981. The Ancient Craft of Granulation. Gold Bulletin 3, 119–129.
Yakar, J. 1985. Regional and Local Schools of Metalwork in Early Bronze Age Anatolia. Part II. Anatolian Studies 35, 25–38.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The authors retain full copyright on the articles or other publications.
All materials are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives 4.0 International License, under which materials may be distributed or reproduced freely, provided the original is unchanged and is quoted correctly.
