Проблемът с „махайрата“ от Софрониево
The so-called makhaira from the village of Sofronievo
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.57573/be-ja.15.289-296Keywords:
Early Iron Age, swords with T-shaped hilts, cross-shaped axe, makhairaAbstract
The sword from the village of Sofronievo, Vratsa region, has long been accepted as the earliest representative of the makhaira type swords in Thrace. However, a re-examination of this weapon reveals significant discrepancies with its initial interpretation. Analysis of archival data and direct observation of the artifact show that the “handle” is actually a type III3B cross-shaped axe (according to Wesse’s typology), which was incorrectly identified as the handle of the blade found in the same complex. This interpretation was probably suggested because the working edge of the axe is also damaged, as can be seen in the photograph in the original publication. For this reason, the axe was later attached (welded) to the blade of the sword during the subsequent restoration. Furthermore, the discrepancies between the original publication of the weapon and its current condition indicate that the interventions made were not adequately documented. A comparative analysis with similar artefacts suggests that the blade is more like the swords of the Basarabi type. These observations require a reassessment of the find and its place in the classification of Thracian offensive weapons. The incorrect interpretation of the sword from Sofronievo highlights the importance of critical rethinking of previously published materials and their significance for refining the typology and chronology of Iron Age weapons in Thrace
Downloads
References
Agre, D. 2011. The tumulus of Golyamata mogila near the villages of Malomirovo and Zlatinitsa. Sofia: Avalon Publishing.
Buyukliev, H. 1981. Napadatelno vaorazhenie v drevna Trakia (kraya na XII v. pr. n.e. – 45 g. ot n.e.). Disertatsia za prisazhdane na obrazovatelnata i nauchna stepen kandidat na istoricheskite nauki. Sofia, AIM–BAN (in Bulgarian).
Cărăbiși, V.-Ș. 2018–2019. Short single-edge curved swords with a bent hilt in the Early Iron Age: A discussion on the stage of the research. Dacia LXII–LXIII, 117–167.
Fol, A., Lichardus, J., Nikolov, V. (еds) 2004. Die Thraker. Das goldene Reich des Orpheus. Katalog-Handbuch zur Ausstellung. Mainz am Rhein: Verlag Philipp von Zabern.
Gergova, D. 1987. Fruh-und alteeisenzeitliche Fibeln aus Bulgairen (Prahistorische Bronzefunde, Abt XIV, Band 7). Munchen: C. H. Beck.
Hänsel, B. 1976. Beiträge zur regionalen und chronologischen Gliederung der älteren Hallstattzeit an der unteren Donau. Bonn: Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt.
Heilmann, D. 2016. Contextualising bow fibulae with Boeotian shield plates: Cultural transfer processes during Early Iron Age in the Central Balkan area. Starinar 66, 9–26. https://doi.org/10.2298/STA1666009H
Iliev, I. 2020. Antichni mechove i boyni nozhove ot Istoricheski muzei – Dulgopol. Zhurnal za istoricheski i arheologicheski izsledvania 1, 7–34 (in Bulgarian).
Ivanov, D. 2000. Kolektsiya “Ares”. Sofia: Univerditetsko izdatelstvo “St. Kliment Ohridski” (in Bulgarian).
Karadzhinov, I. 2023. Tri nepublikuvani zhelezni mecha s ezichesta drazhka ot Severna Bulgaria. Zhurnal za istoricheski i arheologicheski izsledvania 2–3, 7–51 (in Bulgarian).
Marazov, I. 1981. Trakiiski tip nachelnitzi. Problemi na izkustvoto 1, 19–27 (in Bulgarian).
Marazov, I. 1996. Rogozenskoto sakrovishte. Sofia: IK “Sektor” (in Bulgarian).
Nikolov, B. 1965. Trakiyski pametnitsi vav Vrachansko. Izvestia na Arheologicheskia institut 28, 163–202.
Radoslavova, G. 2006. Kimeriyski nahodki ot teritoriyata na kusnoantichnata krepost Abritus. Helis 5, 313–314 (in Bulgarian).
Stoichev, R. 2009. Phiala mesomphalos v Trakia. Opit za klasifikatsia (Studii Kulturno nasledstvo 1). Sofia: Izdatelstvo na Nov Balgarski Universitet (in Bulgarian).
Teržan, B. 1987. The Early Iron Age Chronology of the Central Balkans. Archaeologia Iugoslavica 24, 7–27.
Torbov, N. 2016. Ot kamaka do baruta – sbirka Vatevi. Antichno vaorazhenie. Sofia: Izdatelstvo TON (in Bulgarian).
Torbov, N. 2018. Nozhat makhaira ili sica, orazhie ot II v. pr.Hr. – nachaloto na II v. Sofia: ProVias (in Bulgarian).
Torbov, N. 2020. Antichni mechove ot Balgaria La Tène C – La Tène D. Sofia: ProVias (in Bulgarian).
Venedikov, I. 1957. Trakiyskata yuzda. Izvestiya na Arheologicheskia institut 21, 153–201 (in Bulgarian).
Wesse, A. 1990. Die Ärmchenbeile der Alten Welt: Ein Beitrag zum Beginn der Eisenzeit im östlichen Mitteleuropa (Universitätsforschungen zur prähistorischen Archäologie, Band 3). Bonn: Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The authors retain full copyright on the articles or other publications.
All materials are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives 4.0 International License, under which materials may be distributed or reproduced freely, provided the original is unchanged and is quoted correctly.
